I tend to believe the Shively marriage and record of children belongs to Balthazar’s daughter due to the name of child 4 and the fact that she died in Columbiana Co., OH.
Children: (note, one named Baltzer but none named Jacob)
1. John SHIVELY
2.+Eva SHIVELY
3. Mary SHIVELY
4. Baltzer SHIVELY

Eva Shively:
BIRTH: 3 SEP 1814, , Columbiana co., Ohio
Family 1: James OILER
MARRIAGE: 18 SEP 1853
Family 2: Jacob BARD
MARRIAGE: BEF 1853
1. Debora BARD
2. Hannah BARD
3. Henry BARD
4. Jeremiah BARD
5. Eliza BARD