From the notes of Merry Anne Pierson:
Article on the Caldwell family says her name was FLAKE and that they had 10 children, these children named except for the 10th. p. 98 Meigs County

Children
1. Annaliza CALDWELL b: 1836
2. Sarah Esther CALDWELL b: 9 Jul 1838
3. Samuel Marcellus CALDWELL b: 24 Nov 1840
4. William Marion CALDWELL b: 1844
5. George Jacob F. CALDWELL b: 30 Jun 1847
6. John H. CALDWELL b: 14 Feb 1848
7. Benjamin "Franklin" CALDWELL b: 1850 - listede as Franklin in the 1850 census.
8. Elizabeth Evelyne CALDWELL b: 25 Aug 1853
9. Isabella Evadine CALDWELL b: 1857
10. Francis Emma CALDWELL b: 1859
---
Listed in the 1850 census on page 150 adjcent to Father, Sister in law Saphronia (Smart) Caldwell and her brother Francis Smart

1860 Census?
Wm Caldwelll’s Children are:
Ann E
Sarah E
Samuel M
William M
George J.
John H
Benjamin F
Elizabeth E
Isabella E
Francis E